I picked up the borrowed bandsaw from Co-pilot Rick last night, and tonight I used it to re-cut the part that I messed up so badly with the jigsaw. The top of the ruined board was actually still usable as a template for marking the cut line on the new board, so that only took a matter of moments to trace, and it was off to the saw:
Ahhhh, that's better:
I went ahead and cut the second piece, and they match fairly well:
If you get right up close, you can see where they don't exactly match:
Ok, who's got a belt sander??